2010 Q3 | One Step Back, Two Steps Forward

Jim Hardesty PortraitThe third quarter of 2010 was a remarkable one for stocks and bonds. As is rarely the case, both performed exceptionally well. We do not anticipate this unusual trend will continue much longer. It is, however, very nice to have both major components of our clients’ portfolios performing so well at the same time.

A major reason for the strong quarter in stocks was the shift in the consensus view of the economy. In the beginning of the quarter, most pundits (not us, I might add) were calling for a “double-dip” recession.  This was a step backwards for the market. By the end of August, that view began to shift towards our belief that the economy would avoid another recession.  Clearly, two steps forward. Sentiment shifted because the economic data overall began to turn slightly more positive. With this shift in sentiment, the market rallied. By the end of the quarter, the Dow Jones Industrial Average was almost back to 11,000. (more…)

Continue reading →

2010 Q2 | Headlines, not Fundamentals, Driving Markets

The second quarter was punctuated by two major crises: the European financial crisis and the BP oil disaster. Both dramatically affected the market and both arguably had very little impact on our economy. When we look beyond these two headline-grabbing events, we see a continuation of the economic recovery. This market downturn should prove to be a buying opportunity. (more…)

Continue reading →

2010 Q1 | Recovery… So Far So Good

Jim HardestyThe U.S. economy has continued the recovery that began late in 2009. We expect first quarter 2010 growth to be around 3.5%. The recovery is currently being stimulated by improvements in manufacturing, specifically automobiles, as well as a general rebuilding of inventories throughout the economy. Inventories declined as much as 15% at the trough of the recession. First quarter economic results will be adversely affected by the awful weather conditions that affected the entire northern half of the United States, but we believe the next step in the recovery will be in the housing sector and should occur this spring.

Representing about 10% of the economy, housing is influenced by seasonal economic adjustments that, by reason of the weather, sent confusing signals. Existing home sales are at an annual rate of 5,020,000 units, up from a low of 4,610,000 in the second quarter of 2009. Though still below optimal levels, we remain optimistic, as low mortgage rates (about 5% for a 30-year fixed rate) should continue to stimulate housing demand. In addition, the home buyer’s tax credit, which expires in April, continues to help. Hopefully, the second quarter, which is typically a much stronger quarter for housing, will lead to a growing consensus that the recovery is gaining momentum. (more…)

Continue reading →

2009 Q4 | 2009… A Wild Ride

Jim HardestyThe 4th quarter was another good one for the stock market, marking its third consecutive advance. As a leading indicator for the economy, the market is signaling investors the recovery is real. Where there are still plenty of skeptics, it would appear to us the improving economic data is forming a base upon which a meaningful, sustainable economic recovery can occur.

For the quarter, the S&P 500 returned 6.01%. You may recall the 2nd and 3rd quarters returned 15.94% and 15.56%, respectively. From the index’s trough on March 9, 2009, the S&P 500 has returned 67.8%, one of the strongest nine-month periods in the history of the index. The Dow Jones Industrial Average returned 59.8% over the same time period. For the full year 2009, the S&P 500, Dow and Nasdaq returned 26.50%, 22.60% and 43.91%, respectively. After an abysmal 2008, these results were well-received.

As the stock market began its recovery, the bond market moved in the opposite direction. In the first half of 2009, we saw interest rates move to historic lows as the government continued to work to grease the skids of the credit markets. As these programs began to have a positive effect, interest rates began moving higher. By the end of the year, those rates were much higher. The 10-year Treasury started 2009 yielding 2.20% and ended it yielding 3.79%. As you will recall, when yields rise, bond prices fall. Most Treasuries provided investors with a negative return for the year. Because of the perceived risks in Corporate and Municipal bonds during the year, their yields did not drop as much. The result for investors was that bonds produced positive returns for the year. The Barclays Corporate Index returned 5.24% for the year and the Barclay’s Municipal Index returned 7.61%. (more…)

Continue reading →

2009 Q3 | Economic Growth Returns — Markets Respond

Jim HardestyThe domestic economy most likely turned up in the third quarter of 2009, abating fears of a major economic depression. Seven of the ten leading indicators are now positively contributing to the Index of Leading Economic Indicators. The economic dislocations of 2007 and 2008 are receding. One of the leading indicators, the S&P 500 Index, delivered another very strong quarter, making it two consecutive double-digit percentage increases. The S&P rose 15.6%, the Dow was up 15.7% and the NASDAQ jumped 15.7%. Last quarter, these indexes increased 15.9%, 11.9% and 20.0%, respectively. These results are the best quarterly returns in a decade. Even after this tremendous run, the S&P 500 is still almost 15% below the level experienced when Lehman Brothers declared bankruptcy on September 15, 2008. (more…)

Continue reading →

2009 Q2 | The Sun Peeks Through the Clouds

Jim HardestyAfter reading William Cohan’s book “House of Cards,” I was taken aback by the level of greed that has tarnished respected financial institutions. Greed turned them into financial casinos where executive compensation levels became an overriding corporate objective. This excess is wrong and, just as the excesses of Drexel Burnham in the late 1980’s were corrected, today’s unwarranted and unnecessary compensation levels will eventually return to some form of sanity and normalcy.

Greed was not restricted to the corporate suites of managements across the country. Unfortunately, more financial thievery was exposed this quarter as the public confidence in the U. S. financial markets had to withstand another indictment. Just as the Madoff case came to an end with a 150 year sentence, Mr. R. Allen Stanford, a Houston based financier, who operated significant offshore tax havens, was indicted. To our delight, the sheriff is here, and hopefully those that have abused the financial structure of our economy will be awarded a full measure of the prison sentences and fines they deserve. This is a precondition for restoring investor confidence, which should result in more normal equity valuations. “Normalcy” could equate to more than 50% above current stock prices. (See the Schopf Stop for more on this.) (more…)

Continue reading →

2009 Q1 | Bear Market Rally?

Jim HardestyIs this rally for real? On March 6, the S&P 500 hit a low of 666.8. Since then, the index is up to 797.9, a very impressive recovery in a short period of time. In the closing three weeks of the quarter, we have seen a 16.8% gain in the index. Investors are cautious, however— we have seen promising 10% gains wiped out three times since September. This gut-wrenching market appears to be pricing in a tremendous amount of bad news. Hope that the Obama administration would usher in a more optimistic mood was quickly dashed as the S&P 500 in January and February returned -8.3% and -10.8%, respectively. For the quarter, the S&P was down 10.9%.

To be sure, the recent economic numbers remain gloomy. The Gross Domestic Product fell at an annual rate of 6.3% in the fourth quarter of 2008. A similar decline is likely in the first quarter of 2009. This is the worst back-to-back quarterly performance since the fourth quarter of 1981 and first quarter of 1982. Unemployment spiked to 8.1% and will likely go higher, possibly exceeding 10% in the second half of 2009. The manufacturing and service sectors both continue to contract. All in all, the economy is performing very poorly.

There are, however, early signs of economic stability. The housing market is showing glimmers of hope as new home starts are up and housing affordability is at record highs. Inflation, the enemy of financial assets, is well under control as commodity prices have fallen dramatically from their speculative excesses. Historically low interest rates, combined with government-led programs, have allowed the credit markets to return to some semblance of normalcy. Finally, the strengthening dollar is a very good indication that the economy is beginning to turn. (more…)

Continue reading →

2008 Q4 | 2008… Good Riddance!

Jim HardestyIt was another difficult quarter for the stock market as measured by the S&P 500. Equity prices declined 21.8%, resulting in the worst quarterly performance since the market crash during the fourth quarter of 1987. For the year, the market declined 37.0%, the second worst year in the history of the stock market and the steepest one-year decline since 1931. Not surprisingly, the economic conditions deteriorated as housing prices continued to fall and foreclosure rates in many markets rose sharply.

Employment levels also declined and the unemployment rate increased to 6.7% in the third quarter, up sharply from 5.0% at the outset of the year. This was still much better than the 8.9% unemployment level seen in the second quarter of 1975, the last serious recession since 1931. By comparison, unemployment levels of the depression years, 1933 – 1937, ranged from 14-25%. (more…)

Continue reading →

2008 Q3 | Is the Sky Really Falling?

Jim HardestyIn the third quarter of 2008, the markets experienced the most serious challenge to world financial stability since the depression of the 1930s. What began in early 2007 with a sharp upturn in subprime mortgage delinquencies spread into commercial banks, insurance companies, and investment banking firms. By quarter’s end, the world’s credit markets were in a state of seizure. Investors and borrowers began to lose confidence in our leading financial institutions and volatility reached extremely high levels. In particular, equity prices fell sharply, reacting to seemingly unbelievable developments in the individual financial institutions.

As the quarter came to a close, some of our nation’s largest institutions had either ceased to exist or were in the process of radically changing their business models. Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley experienced 40% declines in stock values, in just three days, victims of short-sellers and hedge funds. By the week ended September 19th, Morgan and Goldman announced plans to reorganize as bank holding companies. In a single six-month period, all five of America’s major investment banking firms (Bear Stearns, Merrill Lynch, Lehman Brothers, Goldman Sachs, and Morgan Stanley) either merged with a bank, reorganized, or filed for bankruptcy. The end of America’s leadership in investment banking would have been unthinkable at the start of the third quarter of 2008.

Commercial banks were also swept into the maelstrom. Wachovia Bank’s stock fell from 60 in early 2007, to as low as 10 on September 26, 2008. As deposits fled, Wachovia was forced into a merger with Citigroup, which was announced on September 29th. This followed the merger of Washington Mutual, our nation’s largest thrift, into J. P. Morgan, which had occurred earlier in the same week. As the leading originator of many of the subprime mortgages, Washington Mutual was taken over by the Office of Thrift Supervision and forced to accept merger terms very favorable to J. P. Morgan. Even the old-line banks such as Fifth Third Bank of Cincinnati, National City and KeyCorp (both Cleveland-based banks), and Regions Financial of Birmingham experienced share price declines of 70% or more, frightening investors and depositors. (more…)

Continue reading →

2008 Q2 | Market Turmoil Continues

Jim Hardesty It was another disappointing quarter for the financial markets as investors remained cautious in the face of high energy prices and continued weakness in the housing market. Uncertainty regarding the Federal Reserve’s course of action in dealing with the economic weakness and credit market issues has also constrained investors. For the quarter, the Dow Jones Industrial Average was off 6.9% following a decline of 6.8% in the first quarter, bringing the year-to-date decline to 13.3%. The month of June was the worst June since 1930, as the Dow was off 10.0%. The S&P 500 was down 11.9% in the first-half. Other indices reported similar first-half results, with the NASDAQ down 13.5% and the Russell 2000, an index of small capitalization companies, off 10.0%. Stock prices tumbled in the quarter due to an especially poor performance by the financial sector. Although J.P. Morgan Chase successfully completed its merger with the failing Bear Stearns, continued problems remain in the sector. The rescue of Bear Stearns was necessary because its business model was not adequately diversified, as it was dependent primarily on sub-prime mortgages and newer “experimental” derivative products, such as credit default instruments.

It was not much better in the bond market as yields across the U.S. Treasury curve moved higher by about a half percent, driving bond prices down during the quarter. For the year, though, yields are essentially unchanged. The yield on the 10-year Treasury, for example, was 3.94% at the end of the period versus 4.15 % on December 31st. (more…)

Continue reading →

2008 Q1 | “The Sun’ll Come Out Tomorrow…” – Annie

Jim HardestyAbout the best that can be said for the first quarter of 2008 is that it is over. The economy weakened in the quarter as continued worsening conditions in the housing market spread to the broader consumer sector. By quarter’s end, there were new signs of troubles in the capital spending sector of the economy. All of the developments were further burdened by extremely high oil prices, which briefly exceeded $110 a barrel in the quarter. The stubborn and surprising unity of the OPEC oil cartel is now having a negative impact on the developed, developing and, especially, the third world countries.

Economic jitters spread through the financial markets in the first quarter, fueled by concerns that some of the newer synthetic financial securities, engineered by Wall Street, were coming unhinged. The loss of  confidence reflected in the absence of liquidity in many of these exotic securities caused dislocations in the markets. Although most of the securities were held by large financial institutions all over the world, many were held by “sophisticated” hedge funds and other investment novelty organizations. Indeed, some notable hedge funds failed because of it, including one run by the once well-regarded Carlyle Group. (more…)

Continue reading →